Dear Comrades

When Ital­ian stu­dents estab­lished some nascent inde­pen­dence from their offi­cial orga­ni­za­tions in 1968, sec­tions of the move­ment called for greater con­tact with indus­trial labor. At the time, they knew where to find them. The Left had flirted with a strate­gic alliance between tech­ni­cal, white-collar work­ers and stu­dents, a link that made sense given the former’s aca­d­e­mic train­ing. But the inter­est proved to be ephemeral. As the strug­gles of South­ern migrants work­ing in the North­ern fac­to­ries of FIAT esca­lated, the stu­dents opted to forgo tech­ni­cians as the “ideal vec­tor” between them­selves and the work­ing class. Uni­ver­sity rad­i­cals dodged unions, too, instead forg­ing direct links at the gates of auto­mo­bile fac­to­ries, where they dis­trib­uted lit­er­a­ture and held assem­blies. Mil­i­tant strikes grew more fre­quent and stu­dent rev­o­lu­tion­ar­ies clam­ored to come into con­tact with history’s appar­ent vanguard.

The worker-student assem­bly became a prin­ci­pal orga­ni­za­tional form dur­ing this cycle of strug­gle. Much of its work involved the pro­duc­tion of lit­er­a­ture for dis­tri­b­u­tion in the fac­to­ries. After work, labor­ers would rush to the gates and recount what had hap­pened that day. The stu­dents took duti­ful notes, and stayed up until the early morn­ing hours fash­ion­ing them into weapons. These pam­phlets were impor­tant cir­cuits of com­mu­ni­ca­tion, an alter­na­tive cur­rent for work­place coop­er­a­tion, which encour­aged rather than repressed mil­i­tancy, while evad­ing union chan­nels that would have had the oppo­site effect. The prac­tice engen­dered last­ing rela­tion­ships between mil­i­tants and the mass worker, giv­ing rise to more for­mal orga­ni­za­tions like Lotta Con­tinua (Con­tin­u­ous Strug­gle). The impor­tance of col­lab­o­ra­tive the­o­ret­i­cal pro­duc­tion was not lost on these new group­ings of intel­lec­tual and man­ual labor – Lotta Con­tinua ran a widely read news­pa­per. Its pages weren’t just filled with reports of tac­ti­cal inven­tions in the fac­to­ries; in some respects, it was its own innovation.

One of the paper’s most pop­u­lar ele­ments was Gas­parazzo, a comic strip char­ac­ter who turned the moral con­dem­na­tions of lazi­ness issued by bosses and bureau­crats alike into a point of pride. Draw­ing ref­er­ences from a shared cul­ture of strug­gle, the comic pro­tag­o­nist rep­re­sented the ten­sion between a sub­ject that work­ers could iden­tify with, and the iconic rev­o­lu­tion­ary that Lotta Con­tinua hoped to meet. The car­toon ele­vated the every­day expe­ri­ence of the mass worker into an ani­mat­ing force of rev­o­lu­tion. What’s more, mil­i­tants work­ing from the very shop floor cul­tures that were dis­cov­ered and devel­oped by the comic strip, gen­er­al­ized the mass worker’s ten­dency toward list­less­ness on the job into a tac­ti­cal inter­rup­tion of cap­i­tal­ist val­oriza­tion. Slow­ing down pro­duc­tion became a favorite expres­sion of their oppo­si­tion to the Tay­lorist orga­ni­za­tion of the workplace.

Much credit is due to the strip’s cre­ator, Roberto Zamarin, a graphic designer who boasted an impres­sive pro­fes­sional career before devot­ing him­self to the agit­prop of the extra­parlia­men­tary Left. But his work was the prod­uct of a con­tin­ued encounter between com­mu­nists and fac­tory labor, with­out which Gas­parazzo would have been impossible.

Zamarin would die in 1972, his hero shortly after. The restruc­tur­ing of the FIAT’s pro­duc­tion process in the early 1970s came with mas­sive lay­offs, which hit shop floor rad­i­cals harder than most. It also made the slow-down tac­tic dif­fi­cult, if not impos­si­ble to employ. Luck­ily, Gasparazzo’s fam­ily, under a diverse array of ban­ners and a plu­ral­ity of move­ments, would carry on the anti-capitalist resistance.

From the per­spec­tive of stu­dents and aca­d­e­mic work­ers, the con­cept of the van­guard had engen­dered cross-class rela­tion­ships with an indus­trial work­ing class, which in turn informed the strate­gic and orga­ni­za­tional con­tent of their com­bined resis­tance. But those mod­els found lim­ited pur­chase as the objec­tive sit­u­a­tion changed. When the insur­gent FIAT employ­ees were hit with tar­geted fir­ings and lay­offs, the util­ity of old forms faded, and dif­fi­cul­ties in trans­lat­ing the industry-based per­spec­tive to new move­ments out­side the fac­tory gates threw groups like Lotta Con­tinua into cri­sis. The grow­ing rifts in the party, par­tic­u­larly between fem­i­nists and male fac­tory work­ers, exploded dur­ing a party con­fer­ence in 1976. Reflect­ing on this chang­ing class com­po­si­tion, the party decided to dis­solve itself.

Despite the larger col­lapse, the organization’s edi­to­r­ial col­lec­tive con­tin­ued to pub­lish Lotta Con­tinua as a news­pa­per with­out a party. Attempt­ing to over­come its dis­tance from exist­ing move­ments, the paper opened a read­ers’ let­ters sec­tion for its daily pub­li­ca­tion in 1977, titled “Dear Com­rades,” and Lotta Con­tinua’s cir­cu­la­tion swelled. In a period of six years, over 8,000 let­ters were sub­mit­ted, and a siz­able num­ber of them – 1,000, in fact – were pub­lished. In 1980, the London-based pub­lisher Pluto Press pre­sented 350 of these let­ters in Eng­lish translation.

The hope and fear that so often join new weapons also accom­pany these let­ters. Yet we should avoid being too sen­ti­men­tal about these sto­ries of inter­per­sonal cri­sis, lest we over­look the cri­sis of polit­i­cal forms that gave rise to them. The let­ters sec­tion was a response to a very spe­cific con­junc­ture, in which pro­le­tar­ian activ­ity was both dis­parate and unknown. When the gates where stu­dents met “history’s van­guard” were either miss­ing or locked, rev­o­lu­tion­ar­ies dis­solved the old orga­ni­za­tional forms based on yesterday’s alliances. With new sub­jects, “Dear Com­rades” wrote towards a dif­fer­ent kind of coop­er­a­tion. Most of the let­ters con­tain at least a trace of desire for an encounter across sec­tions of the class. But it is often more explicit than that. Immi­grants ask for more socially immer­sive orga­niz­ing and out­reach. Moth­ers write for sons to come home. Pris­on­ers want pen pals, and one man really needs the rabble-rouser who bor­rowed his bike at the demon­stra­tion to return it. Even reflec­tions on com­mu­nist strat­egy pro­vide an address so some­one can fol­low up the debate. There is plenty of talk about ene­mies and what to do with them. But the col­umn was addressed to com­rades, and it is the prac­tice of friend­ship that seems most pressing.

Dear Com­rades was the crit­i­cal infra­struc­ture that simul­ta­ne­ously dis­cov­ered the pre­vail­ing need for com­mu­ni­ca­tion in the class, while mak­ing mod­est ges­tures towards sat­is­fy­ing it. Our sit­u­a­tion is not that dif­fer­ent – the orga­ni­za­tional forms and tac­tics of Occupy have faded, but peo­ple and their net­works are still try­ing to per­sist. We still can’t find the gates of “history’s van­guard,” but that might be rea­son to cel­e­brate; encoun­ters never take hold with­out sur­prise. It is towards this goal that we revive the prac­tice here.

  • The Precarious World of Those Who Answer Your Customer Service Calls Issue # 451
  • The Pathology of the Rich White Family Issue # 449
  • How Lady Day found herself in the middle of the Federal Bureau of Narcotics' early fight for survival Issue # 448
  • The Power of Political Athletes to Puncture Privilege Issue # 447
  • The Senate Torture Report: Who Will Be Held Responsible? - See more at: http://portside.org/2014-12-13/senate-torture-report-who-will-be-held-responsible#sthash.QOoIlALO.dpuf Issue # 446
  • Dead Labor on a Dead Planet: The Inconvenient Truth of Workers' Bladders Issue # 445
  • The Rhetoric of Violence Issue # 444
  • "Bonus Babies" Issue # 442
  • Starving College Students and the Shredded Social Contract Issue # 441
  • Ukraine’s Nationalist Spectre Issue # 439
  • Iraq Near Implosion The 'Bad Years' Are Back Issue # 438
  • Millennials: Hold ‘Obamacare’ hostage Issue # 437
  • Fast Food Strikes Hit 100 Cities Thursday Issue # 436
  • The Alcatraz Proclamation: Proclamation to the Great White Father and All His People Issue # 435
  • Occupy’s Rolling Jubilee just freed thousands of people from $15 million in debt Issue # 434
  • At SWAT team expo, protesters decry police militarization Issue # 433
  • Video Released: Edward Snowden at Sam Adams Award Ceremony Issue # 432
  • Dear Comrades Issue # 431
  • Manning and Snowden Light Path for the US to Return to Its Better Self Issue # 430
  • Celebrations and Dangers for Egypt's Revolutions Issue # 429
  • The Good Germans in Government Issue # 428
  • Investigate Booz Allen Hamilton, Not Edward Snowden Issue # 427
  • Four Numbers That Everyone Needs to Know About Drone Strikes Issue # 426
  • We've Moved on from the Iraq War – But Iraqis Don't Have that Choice Issue # 425
  • The Execution of Christopher Dorner Issue # 424
  • Makers, Takers and $2-a-dayers Issue # 419
  • After Fukushima: Enough Is Enough Issue # 418
  • The Abandoned Class Issue # 417
  • Walmart: Too Big to Sue? Issue # 416
  • Egypt's IMF-Backed Revolution? No Thanks Issue # 415
  • Forget Sarah Palin and Donald Trump: Obama Needs a Challenge from the Left If the president had a Democratic opponent in the primaries it might stop him repeatedly triangulating to the right Issue # 414
  • Let’s Admit the Truth About American Royals Issue # 413
  • Quarter-Million Dead and Not Counting Issue # 412
  • Poverty in John Boehner's District Issue # 411
  • Bring War Dollars Home by Closing Down Bases Issue # 410
  • Want to Cut the Deficit? Restore Fair Taxes on Corporations and the Wealthy Issue # 409
  • Peter King’s Muslim McCarthyism Issue # 408
  • Bradley Manning Could Face Death: For What? Issue # 407
  • Attacks on Unions Barking Up the Wrong Money Tree Issue # 406
  • Bahrain Royal Family Orders Army to Turn on the People Issue # 405
  • The Leaked Campaign to Attack WikiLeaks and Its Supporters by Glenn Greenwald Issue # 404
  • Reagan's Real Legacy Issue # 403
  • US Troops Die Because of Their Country, Not For It Issue # 402
  • Freedom of Choice: Living for What You Would Die For Issue # 401
  • The Vindication (by Barack Obama) of Dick Cheney Issue # 400
  • The Disruptive Drip of WikiLeaks and the Public's Right to Know Issue # 399
  • War is a Drug: Washington's 30-Year High Issue # 398
  • Pharmaceutical Industry Fraud Issue # 397
  • To the Gay Community: Now That You Can Join the Military, Please Don’t! Issue # 396
  • What PBS Thinks You Need to Know: Replacement for Now & Moyers fails to fill their shoes Issue # 395
  • “Why Is the U.S. Government Deaf to What Has Been Done to My Son?” Asks Father of an American Murdered on the Gaza Flotilla Issue # 394
  • “Making Ends Meet in Coin-Operated Washington” (with apologies to the late, great Damon Runyon) Issue # 393
  • Occupied Palestine Not 'Settling' for Nothing: The cessation of the settlement moratorium was never in doubt to the Palestinian residents of Wadi Rahaal. Issue # 392
  • No Happy Ending in Honduras: The Central American nation's woes continue to rage despite Secretary of State Clinton's insistence to the contrary. Issue # 391
  • Afghan War Myths Issue # 390
  • They Kill Alex Issue # 389
  • The Casualties of Cluster Bombs Must Not Be Forgotten Issue # 388
  • "There Are No Heroes in Illegal and Immoral Wars" Issue # 387
  • What Mid-terms? It’s All About Paying the Bills Issue # 386
  • Imperial Overkill and the Death of US Empire Issue # 385